This opinion round-up from the Marin IJ’s Dec. 17, 2025 Readers’ Forum captures a cross-section of Marin County’s biggest debates. The topics range from homelessness in San Rafael and immigration enforcement in San Rafael and Novato, to clean energy in Corte Madera and Mill Valley, climate policy in Larkspur and Fairfax, and the future of our economy from Sausalito to Novato.
The letters, written by neighbors from across Marin, show how national issues land right here at home. You see it along Highway 101 and on the shores of San Pablo Bay.
Discover hand-picked hotels and vacation homes tailored for every traveler. Skip booking fees and secure your dream stay today with real-time availability!
Browse Accommodations Now
Homelessness in San Rafael: Tiny Homes, Big Emotions
In San Rafael, a proposed temporary tiny-home shelter on Merrydale Road has turned into a lightning rod for a classic Marin County battle. It’s compassion versus convenience, and the arguments get heated.
One San Rafael resident says the project is a modest, humane response to the visible homelessness that people see every day in Terra Linda, downtown San Rafael, and along the freeway corridors. Opposition from nearby neighbors often comes off as thinly veiled NIMBYism — folks want solutions, but only if they happen somewhere else, far from the quiet cul-de-sacs of Santa Venetia, the townhomes of Marinwood, or the hills above Greenbrae.
Compassion in an Affluent County
The letter pushes back against the idea that affluent communities like Ross, Tiburon, Belvedere, and Kentfield can keep their comfort by pushing the most vulnerable residents out of sight. In a county that prides itself on progressive values, the writer asks for compassion in action: supporting small-scale, managed shelters and housing options as a step toward stability for people living on our streets, in cars, or in precarious spots from Novato to Mill Valley.
Immigration Enforcement and Marin’s Values
From Mill Valley, a resident challenges Marin County’s role in federal immigration enforcement. They urge county leaders to stop taking federal SCAAP funds, which come with the requirement to share jail and arrest info with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) — a practice that can affect families from San Rafael’s Canal neighborhood to apartment complexes in San Anselmo and Novato.
The writer points out that Marin doesn’t have to provide this data and says that continuing the practice goes against the values voters in Fairfax, Larkspur, Corte Madera, and beyond showed when they rejected Trump-era immigration policies.
Transparency from Supervisors and the Sheriff
Concerns focus on wrongful detentions, inhumane conditions in detention centers, and limited access to attorneys. The letter calls for swift, public action by the Board of Supervisors and the sheriff’s office in San Rafael, asking for open meetings, clear explanations, and policy changes that better match Marin’s self-image as a sanctuary-minded county.
Local Energy Control: MCE at 15 Years
On the energy front, a regional economic development leader marks the 15th anniversary of MCE (formerly Marin Clean Energy), which started in places like San Rafael and Fairfax and now reaches into Solano County. The letter credits MCE for giving local governments — from Novato City Hall to Sausalito’s council chambers — more control over how electricity gets sourced and priced.
The writer says community choice aggregation has helped stabilize rates, created green jobs, and sped up the shift toward renewable power for homes and businesses from Marin City to Tiburon.
Community Choice and Local Jobs
MCE’s outreach and education, the letter notes, have made it easier for residents in Mill Valley, Larkspur, and Corte Madera to understand their energy options. The benefits include:
With sea level rise threatening Tam Valley and flooding in low-lying parts of San Rafael, local energy governance feels like a vital climate tool.
Rethinking Growth: A “Maintenance Economy” for Marin
Another letter zooms out, questioning the old assumption that economic growth must be endless. The writer warns that on a finite planet, perpetual growth in population and consumption — whether in sprawling suburbs or dense city cores — pushes ecosystems to the brink.
Capitalism’s built-in push for expansion, they say, doesn’t fit with long-term survival, whether you’re looking at wildfire-prone hillsides above Fairfax and San Anselmo or the already stressed shoreline around San Pablo Bay.
From Growth to Sustainability
The writer suggests a “maintenance economy” that focuses on keeping what we have rather than always expanding. That could mean:
For folks in Stinson Beach, Point Reyes Station, and Bolinas, this echoes long-running debates about visitor impacts, housing, and environmental protection.
Climate Policy and the Next Generation
The final letter, from a high school student, addresses Trump-era proposals to weaken vehicle mileage standards. It’s an issue that hits commuters crawling along 101 from Novato to San Francisco, buses rolling through Corte Madera and Larkspur, and families driving kids to school in Mill Valley and San Rafael.
She argues that weaker fuel efficiency rules would worsen climate change and air pollution, hurting public health and passing costs on to her generation and beyond.
Fuel Standards as Climate and Pocketbook Policy
The student points out that strong mileage standards do a few important things:
Her letter really drives home a theme you see all over the Readers’ Forum. Choices made in Washington and Sacramento ripple through daily life in Marin County, whether it’s the tiny-home shelter on Merrydale Road or just the air we breathe and the energy keeping the lights on.
Here is the source article for this story: Marin IJ Readers’ Forum for Dec. 17, 2025
Find available hotels and vacation homes instantly. No fees, best rates guaranteed!
Check Availability Now
Cities and Towns in Marin County
Things to Do in Marin County
Places to Stay in Marin County
